Tuesday, October 17, 2017

TrumpTax Plan for Idiots


Hey, glad to be back with you. 

I've been paying attention to the reform President Trump wants to apply to the current tax code, both personal and corporate.  This has been a major theme of his since he began campaigning.  In fact, he has repeatedly promised to lower the corporate tax rate to 15%.  In fact, let's do the corporate thing first.

“When it comes to the business tax we are dead last, …"  This is technically true.  The statutory corporate tax rate in the U.S.A. is 35%, the highest in the world.  If any corporation paid that it would certainly stifle growth.  However, in perusing the taxes paid by the 10 largest corporations in the Unit4ed States for the past several years I was unable to find any that paid more than 20%.  Most were around 15% and some as low as 5%.  All this information is available in the corporate annual reports.  Let's ignore the POTUS' disingenuous statement and work with 35% as actual accurate and applied number.

So, the 35% is currently proposed to be cut to 20%.  Stop, wait, you say, the President said he would cut the rate to 15%.  He did say that, however, like so many things he has said or promised it has not come to fruition. 

Trump long ago promised to decrease the tax rate to 15% for corporations.  Here's what he said on Wednesday September 27, 2017, "

"In fact, I wanted to start at 15 so that we got to 20,…"

"Twenty is my number, so I'm not negotiating that number," Trump said. "I'm not going to negotiate."

Trump also claimed that 20% was his goal all along, despite advocating for 15% as late as Tuesday.

"That's the number I wanted to get to," the president said. "I wanted to start at 15 to get there. We really had to start there because of the complexity of the numbers, but 20 is a perfect number."

According to the President's own statements he never had any intention of cutting the corporate tax rate 15% although he repeatedly assured America that was his intent.  Oh well, live and learn.

So, we're going to cut 35% to 20% , excellent.  That's a 15% point cut in the statutory rate.  This should result in a reduction of revenue of about 43%.  Just a minute there, how can we have a 43% reduction in revenue when the tax rate was only cut by 15%?  Excellent question young Jedi.  Here's the deal, you were theoretically collecting taxes at a rate of 35%, you will now collect at a rate of 20%, that 15% cut represents 42.85%, let's call it 43% of the rate at which you were collecting.  Here's an example;  35% of $100 is $35.  20% of $100 is $20.  You collected $20 rather than $35, so you collected 20/35 or 57% of your previous collection.  There is your 43% reduction in revenue. 

If I'm a corporation I love this.  I wasn't paying 35% to start with and I'm not any more likely to pay a statutory rate of 20%.  

On to individuals.  Ok, the rates for individuals are a little more diverse.  Here's a table for you:

                               2017                                                     Proposed

10%                $0-$9,325                                            12%   Income not specified

15%                $9326-$37,950                                   12%          "         "         "

______________________________________________________________

25%                $37,951-$91,900                                25%  Income not specified

28%                $91,901-$191,650                              25%        "         "          "

33%                $191,651-$416,700                            25%        "         "          "

______________________________________________________________

 35%               $416,701-$418,400                             35%  Income not specified

39.6%             $418,401 or more                               35%         "        "          "

______________________________________________________________

Standard deduction              $6,350                          $12,000

Personal exemption              $4,050                            Eliminated



Let us review.
If you are the poorest of the poor who are required to pay taxes your are subject to a 20% rate increase.  No doubt this will go far to help make up for the decrease in corporate tax revenue.
The people at the next level will receive a 20% rate decrease.
Folks currently paying 25% get no benefit.  Good, these folks are bearing the majority of the tax burden for the United States now and I see no reason why they should not continue to do so. 
The taxpayers at 28% and 33% will receive a rate reduction of 11% and 24% respectively.  Why shouldn't they?  Their incomes are considerably higher than the median or average for the U.S. 
The people at 35% get nothing and the "elite" earners see a 12% decrease.

The above numbers are for single filers.  For joint filers the percentages remain the same but the income levels differ.

So, the big winners are corporate America and individuals who make the most money.
Be not disheartened.  "And we will make taxes simple, and easy, and fair for all Americans."  DJT. 
Corporate America gets a 43% tax cut, followed by those who make substantially more than the median income, because they deserve it.

Once again the "little guy" gets screwed.  So, if you make $91,901 or more annually, good for you.  If you make less or are poor, fuck you.  What could be more fair than that?
I have to admit, it is simple and easy.  It always has been simpler and easier to tread on the backs of the weakest and poorest.
No doubt, Jesus is proud.

Whaduyathink?